Yellow, thickened, brittle, or discolored toenails can be frustrating. Many patients spend months trying different products, hoping to restore the appearance of their nails, only to see little improvement.

One of the most common questions we hear at Michigan Foot and Ankle Specialists is:

"Do I need a prescription to treat my toenail fungus, or is there something I can buy that actually works?"

The answer may surprise you.

While prescription antifungal medications have an important role in treating toenail fungus (onychomycosis), they aren't always the most convenient, affordable, or practical choice. Some prescription treatments have relatively low success rates, while others can be difficult to obtain because of insurance restrictions and high out-of-pocket costs. Fortunately, there are other options worth discussing.

Let's compare the most common treatments, explain their advantages and limitations, and discuss what we recommend to our patients.

Prescription Topical Treatments: Are They Worth It?

There are several prescription medications specifically designed to treat fungal toenail infections. However, prescription strength doesn't automatically guarantee a successful outcome.

Penlac (Ciclopirox 8%): The Older, Less Effective Option

Ciclopirox 8%, commonly known by its former brand name Penlac, is one of the older prescription treatments for toenail fungus. It is applied as a lacquer that forms a coating over the nail. Patients must apply it regularly and remove accumulated lacquer periodically as directed.

The problem? Its complete cure rate is disappointingly low.

Clinical studies have reported complete cure rates of approximately 5.5% to 8.5%, even after prolonged treatment. That means only a relatively small percentage of patients achieved both a completely clear nail and negative fungal testing. Although generic ciclopirox is relatively inexpensive and frequently covered by insurance, its limited effectiveness makes it a less appealing option for many patients.

At Michigan Foot and Ankle Specialists, we generally prefer to discuss other treatment options rather than rely on ciclopirox alone.

Jublia (Efinaconazole 10%): Better Results, but a Major Cost Problem

Jublia is a newer prescription topical medication developed specifically for toenail fungus. Unlike traditional nail lacquers, Jublia uses a specialized solution designed to spread across the nail and reach areas where fungus may be present. Clinical studies have shown more encouraging results than older topical medications. In two major studies, approximately 15% to 18% of patients achieved a complete cure after 48 weeks of daily treatment, with results evaluated at week 52. That is a meaningful improvement over older prescription topical options.

Our perspective: Jublia is a legitimate, evidence-based treatment. However, its potential benefits must be weighed against cost and accessibility. Even when patients obtain Jublia, daily application for approximately 48 weeks requires a substantial commitment, and complete clearance is far from guaranteed. 

Tavaborole 5% (formerly Kerydin): Another Prescription Alternative

Kerydin, now available as generic tavaborole, is another prescription topical antifungal medication. Its small molecular structure helps it penetrate the nail plate, where fungal infections can be difficult to reach. Clinical trials demonstrated complete cure rates of approximately 6.5% to 9.1% after 48 weeks of daily treatment, with evaluation at week 52. While tavaborole is an effective antifungal medication for some patients, its complete cure rates are still relatively modest. Like Jublia, coverage and affordability can present challenges.

So what's the catch? For many patients, the biggest obstacle isn't whether Jublia or Kerydin can work. It's whether they can actually obtain them. Jublia can be extremely expensive without insurance coverage. Depending on the insurance plan, patients may encounter:

  • Prior authorization requirements

  • High copays or deductibles

  • Formulary restrictions

  • Requirements to try less expensive medications first

  • Complete denial of coverage

The takeaway:

Prescription topical treatments can work, but patients should understand that most insurance companies restrict coverage for newer prescription topical antifungals, and even covered medications may carry substantial copays.  Some insurance plans classify treatment of fungal toenails as cosmetic under certain circumstances or require additional evidence of medical necessity. Unfortunately, this can leave patients frustrated, particularly when their physician has recommended a medication that they cannot reasonably afford. 

What About Nonprescription Toenail Fungus Products?

This is where the conversation becomes interesting. Many patients assume that anything available without a prescription must be inferior to prescription medication. That's not necessarily true when it comes to overall nail care, convenience, and improving the appearance of damaged nails. However, there is an important distinction: Improving how a fungal nail looks is not the same as proving that the underlying fungal infection has been eliminated.

At Michigan Foot and Ankle Specialists, we offer several professionally selected topical products that combine antifungal ingredients with nail-conditioning formulations.

These products are available directly from our office, without the frustration of insurance authorization or prescription coverage restrictions.

Tolcylen Antifungal Nail Renewal Solution: A Game Changer

Tolcylen has become one of our preferred topical nail-care products based on our clinical experience and patient feedback.

Its formulation includes tolnaftate 1%, an established antifungal ingredient for certain fungal skin infections, along with ingredients intended to help condition and improve the appearance of damaged nails. Unlike products that focus exclusively on antifungal activity, Tolcylen also incorporates ingredients such as urea and lactic acid that help address the appearance and texture of thickened, brittle, or discolored nails.

Why do we like Tolcylen?

In our practice, we've been pleased with the cosmetic improvements we've observed in patients who use Tolcylen consistently. It offers several practical advantages:

  • Available directly from our office without a prescription

  • No insurance approval or prior authorization required

  • Combines antifungal and nail-conditioning ingredients

  • Designed to address the appearance of damaged nails

  • Can be incorporated into a physician-directed nail-care routine

We believe it can be a useful option for patients seeking a convenient, professionally selected nail-care product.

Clarus AC: Antifungal Ingredients Plus Nail Conditioning

Clarus AC is another professional topical formulation containing tolnaftate 1%, combined with additional ingredients such as undecylenic acid, lactic acid, urea, vitamin E, and N-acetylcysteine (NAC).

These ingredients distinguish its formulation from other topical nail-care products, with components intended to support conditioning and improve the appearance of damaged nails. Like Tolcylen, Clarus AC is available directly through our office without requiring insurance approval.

Formula 7: Another Professional Nail-Care Option

Formula 7 contains tolnaftate 1% and features a patented microemulsion delivery system designed to help distribute the antifungal ingredient. Its formulation includes N-acetylcysteine (NAC), which the manufacturer describes as a penetration-enhancing ingredient, along with urea, jojoba oil, tea tree oil, and vitamin E to support nail conditioning.

While its specialized formulation offers a different approach to topical nail care, it should not be confused with clinical proof that Formula 7 can eradicate established fungal infections within the nail.

The best choice among these products depends on the condition of the nails, the patient's goals, and the treatment plan recommended during an examination.

Why We Offer These Products in Our Office

At Michigan Foot and Ankle Specialists, we understand how frustrating it can be to receive a prescription only to discover that your insurance company won't cover it—or that your out-of-pocket cost is unexpectedly high. We also understand that not every patient wants to commit to nearly a year of expensive prescription topical treatment.

That's why we offer professionally selected nonprescription products, including Tolcylen, Clarus AC, and Formula 7.

Our goal is to give patients practical options that are readily available, reasonably priced, and appropriate for their individual nail-care needs.

We particularly favor Tolcylen because of the positive experiences we've had with patients using it in our practice. For some patients, a nonprescription nail-care product may be a reasonable choice. For others, prescription treatment or oral medication may be more appropriate.

What About Oral Lamisil? Isn't That More Effective?

Yes! And this is an important part of the discussion.

Oral terbinafine, commonly known by the brand name Lamisil, is generally more effective at treating dermatophyte toenail fungus than topical medications alone. Unlike topical solutions that must penetrate the nail from the outside, oral terbinafine works systemically, reaching the affected nail through the body's circulation.

For appropriate patients, it is often one of the most effective medical treatment options available. A typical course for toenail fungus involves taking terbinafine daily for 12 weeks (90 days).

However, oral antifungal treatment isn't something we prescribe without first performing an appropriate evaluation.

Why We Test the Nail Before Prescribing Lamisil

Not every thick, yellow, or damaged toenail is caused by fungus. Nail trauma, psoriasis, chronic pressure from shoes, and other conditions can produce changes that resemble a fungal infection.

At Michigan Foot and Ankle Specialists, we obtain a nail specimen for laboratory analysis to help confirm the diagnosis before starting oral antifungal medication. This is important because treating a nonfungal nail condition with an oral antifungal medication would expose the patient to unnecessary medication risks without addressing the actual problem.

Why Blood Work Is Important

Oral terbinafine is processed by the liver and can occasionally cause serious liver-related side effects.

Before prescribing it, we evaluate the patient's medical history, medications, and liver health. We also obtain blood work to assess liver function before treatment. Patients with active or chronic liver disease should not take oral terbinafine, and additional monitoring may be appropriate during treatment.

Although most patients tolerate terbinafine well, possible adverse effects and drug interactions must be considered.

Can You Use a Topical Product Alongside Lamisil?

Yes, but it is optional. In some cases, we may recommend a topical nail-care product while a patient is taking oral terbinafine.

The oral medication treats the fungal infection systemically, while the topical product may help support nail care and improve the appearance of damaged nails as they grow. However, adding an OTC topical product has not been conclusively proven to increase cure rates compared with oral terbinafine alone.

And remember: even after the fungus has been successfully treated, the damaged portion of the nail must gradually grow out. A healthy-looking toenail can take many months to develop.

Which Toenail Fungus Treatment Is Right for You?

There is no single treatment that's ideal for every patient. The best approach depends on several factors, including:

  • How many toenails are affected

  • How thick or damaged the nails have become

  • How much of each nail is involved

  • Whether laboratory testing confirms a fungal infection

  • Your medical history and current medications

  • Insurance coverage and treatment costs

  • Whether your primary goal is fungal eradication, cosmetic improvement, or both

Some patients may benefit from prescription topical medication. Others may be candidates for oral terbinafine. And some may prefer to begin with a professionally recommended topical nail-care product.

The most important step is determining what's actually causing the nail changes and choosing a realistic treatment plan.

Get Expert Help for Toenail Fungus in Dearborn, Michigan

If you've been struggling with thick, yellow, brittle, or discolored toenails, you don't have to keep guessing which products to try.

At Michigan Foot and Ankle Specialists, we evaluate nail disorders, offer diagnostic nail testing when appropriate, and help patients understand their treatment options. Whether you're interested in prescription treatment, oral antifungal medication, or one of the professional nail-care products available in our office, we'll help you determine which approach makes the most sense for your situation.

Schedule an appointment with Michigan Foot and Ankle Specialists in Dearborn, Michigan, to discuss your toenail concerns and develop a personalized treatment plan.

Medical disclaimer: This article is intended for general education and does not replace an individualized medical examination. Treatment results vary, and no medication or topical product guarantees complete nail clearance.

Comments are closed.